Wednesday, January 16, 2013

The Show Must Go On

Mike Daisey’s continuation of his theater show after admitting that he was lying is an important contemporary artifact because it demonstrates the tendency of Americans to put morals and facts aside and focus on pure profit. This drive for profit has been embedded in Americans throughout all the time periods that we have studied.

Daisey’s show outlines horrific working conditions and specific stories from workers in one of Apple’s supposed Chinese sweatshops. However, after investigation by reporters, Daisey was forced to come out and admit that the show is just a piece of "theater", and not wholly true. Daisey’s use of the word “theater” indicates that it is merely an attempt to please the audience, not provide facts of a certain situation. A theater show, for example, can act out the brutality and chilling times of the Holocaust, without providing one hundred percent accuracy in its stories.

Daisey’s directors go on to describe that “art is different than journalism.” Art is a form of expression where an artist creates something based on their emotions and understanding of a certain situation. Journalism, in contrast, is limited to providing cold hard facts to a certain audience. A journalist, for example, could detail the horrors of a certain sweat shop and quote the workers about what they go through. An artist, on the other hand, could paint that same worker with blood and tears running over his body. The distinction between art and journalism, though seemingly small, is a clear indication that Daisey fabricated certain parts of his show purely to attract audiences, and ultimately gain profit. The fact that Daisey’s shows continued to run despite being proven false is a clear indication that Daisey just wants his show to make money.

The theme of making money is still present in the modern day. In Mr. O’Connor’s blog post, Polling Matters, he reminds us that “media outlets are businesses.” A business is a company or shop that focuses on buying or selling products in order to make money. The cigarette business, for example, exemplifies that they care only that people buy their product so that they make money, and care less about the negative health issues associated with it.

The drive for profit was clear even during the Salem witch trials. The Englishmen who landed in Salem were “motivated mainly by a hunt for profit” (Crucible 5). The idea of profit is still present during this time period. Profit, as you know, is a drive to make money. The word “hunt” is not only foreshadowing the witch-hunt that ensued in Salem, but also indicates that people are willing to go to extreme lengths to make money. A dog hunts for squirrels so that it has something to eat, similarly to how people hunt for profit. A hunt, to me, indicates that a person will go to all lengths, even kill someone or something, to get what they want. This demonstrates that people will do whatever it takes to get money.

During the Civil War, the drive for profit was also a top priority for most people: “Auctions of slaves took place at public slave markets” (Foner 380). An auction is a place where people sell their goods (or in this case, slaves) for the highest amount of money possible. This is a clear suggestion that the drive for money was preceded morals. During the Civil War, Southerners put morals aside and did all they could to make money.

Throughout the times in history we have studied, the theme of profit preceding morals and common sense has been present, but as they say, the show must go on.

Sunday, January 6, 2013

Forced Labor in China

A couple weeks ago, we had numerous class discussions about modern forms of slavery. We listened to a very intense poem called "Shirt" by Robert Pinsky, and we were then assigned to write a poem or story about modern day slavery in a certain country or factory. Before the assignment, I had never thought much of forced labor, and how big of a role it plays in the American society. A shockingly high 98% of the clothes in America have been imported from other countries, according to ABCNews.  But the problem isn't that we import too much, it's that what we import is made by slave labor in other countries.

Recently, I found a story that details the life of a slave in a factory in Masanjia, China. The story was discovered when a woman and her husband opened a box of Halloween decorations to decorate their house. But when they opened the box, they found more than just the decorations, they found this:



In the letter, a woman from the Masanji Forced Labor camp in China begs whoever opens the item to alert the World Human Rights Assocation about the cruel violations that occur daily. She works fifteen hours a day, gets zero days off. If a worker tries to get a day off, they "will suffer torturement, beat and rude remark". And they only make $1.61 a month.

Yes, the details are horrid, and yes, we should all go out of our way to make sure we stop things like this from happening. But a larger impact would be the impact that items made by slave labor would have on the US companies that sell them. According to Title 19 Section 1307 of the US Code, any item made in a country by forced labor is not legally allowed to come in the US. If these laws were truly followed by the US, I would be interested to see how much of the products and goods we buy are made by forced slave labor.

After all of this, I have been left questioning: Are products made by slaves a part of the American society? Is there anything that we can do to ensure that we don't buy or support slave labor? I think that the Americans rely too much on cheap, slave-made goods in order to make a profit, and that most care more about money than suffering people in other countries. What do you think?

Sunday, December 16, 2012

The Influence of the NFL


During class, we discussed the NFL - its rules, its penalty system, and its influence on kids. The part that I found most interesting was the spillover effect it had on other players in the NFL and of other ages. I especially found the question that Mr. Bolos posed on his blog post interesting. He asked: "Finally, I guess I wonder what you think about the impact of football on young people who play the game and how the NFL doe(s) or does not influence the kids playing at the high school level, for example."

To answer his question, I think that the NFL has a large impact on high-school football. This is especially apparent in two examples that I can remember. Cam Newton, the starting quarterback for the Carolina Panthers, does a touchdown celebration where he acts as if he rips off the shirt from his chest. He does this every time he scores a touchdown, and never gets in trouble for it. However, Jalan McClendon, a high-school quarterback, did the same exact celebration during one of his games, because of how much he looked up to Newton. The celebrations were the same, but the consequences were not. McClendon got ejected from that game because the high school thought it was disrespectful.

Similarly, a well-known football star is Tim Tebow. He also has a coined touchdown celebration called “Tebow-ing” where he kneels over and looks like he is praying. Many young kids, and even adults, mimic this by tebow-ing at any time they deem necessary. Some high-school students at Riverhead High School were suspended for a hallway tebowing session.

Both examples indicate that actions that NFL stars take are often copied by high-schoolers who look up to them. The pattern indicates that the actions the pros take have no consequences, while the kids often do get penalized. Why do you think this is true? Should pros be more careful about their celebrations, or should they continue to do what they do?

Sunday, December 9, 2012

Americans and the Lottery

During this past week, the news was filled with stories not of the situation in Syria, but of the lottery. The Lottery was up to $580 million dollars last week, which was the second highest jackpot in American history. My initial reaction to this was, "here we go again." But the longer I thought about it, the more I connected it to our discussions of success in class.

The craze over the Lottery to me indicates that Americans would much rather get their money in a way that requires absolutely no work, rather than working hard doing a job they love. This fantasy of winning the lottery coerces people to buy a lottery ticket. The interesting thing to me is that the odds of winning are so minuscule, yet thousands upon thousands of people still buy tickets. 

The odds of winning the Jackpot were at 1 in 176 million. That is such a ridiculously small chance of winning that I would think it would turn some people off from buying the tickets. Boy was I wrong about that. Anyway, I found this hilarious Times article that compared the odds of winning the lottery to the odds of other funny, random things. Here are some of my favorites:

Chances of dating a supermodel: 1 in 88,000
Chances of dying by falling off of a ladder: 1 in 2.3 million
Chances of drowning in the bathtub: 1 in 840,000
Chances of dying by getting hit by a vending machine: 1 in 112 million

Despite these odds, Americans don't cease to buy a ticket for a chance to win. This tells me a couple of things about Americans: Like I mentioned earlier, they would rather have to do no work to get an absurd amount of money that they have no need for. Second, that they care more about money than doing what they love. 

Do you think this is the case with all Americans - do they worship money? Or is it just a craze due to the lottery?

Sunday, December 2, 2012

Fiscal Cliff

The fiscal cliff is approaching. And if a deal isn't made before January 1st, our economy will be doomed. There will be spending cuts all across the board in all different sectors of our economy - the defense sector, welfare, etc. This will devastate the economy, the most important possession that the US has.

What intrigues me is how important money is to the US. We care less about fighting in wars, or our troops dying, or anything else really. All that we care about is that we have enough money to sustain those wars, or invest in new technology or infrastrcuture that isn't necessarily essential to helping our country grow stronger.

What also interests me is the vast difference in ideologies between the Republicans and the Democrats in the fiscal cliff negotiations. The Republicans are most concerned with increasing taxes on the wealthy, whereas the Democrats are more concerned about programs like welfare. How does one nation produce such different ideologies when it comes to the economy? What is most important to America right now? Are those priorities correct? Feel free to comment below.

Sunday, November 25, 2012

Kyrsten Sinema

The name may be unfamiliar to you, but Kyrsten Sinema is breaking precedents in Arizona. Although the elections are over, and it seems that almost everyone is tuned out of politics for the next 4 years, I am not. Sinema just recently got elected to the House of Representatives after all of the votes were finally tallied, 6 days after the polls closed. She came out on top, and is now not only a rare Democrat elected in the generally red state of Arizona, but is also the first bisexual congresswoman to be elected.

This groundbreaking achievement of Sinema's is quite important. This victory may lead the way to equal rights for those who are a part of the LGBT community. It is hard enough to win an election as a Democrat in a generally Republican state, but when you defy all odds and win it is even more amazing.

What kind of implications does this victory have for the future of equal rights? Will this boost the chances of other LGBT people who run for Congress' chance of succeeding? Why or why not?

If you want to learn more, here is a two minute video on Sinema.

Sunday, November 18, 2012

Defining Success

Earlier in the week, Mr. O'Connor brought up an idea about how people who live around here quantify success. Not to generalize, but I think it is fair to say that most people around here would define success as getting the best grades, going to the best college, and making the most money. This brief conversation that we had got me thinking about the reasons I put so much effort into getting good grades in school.

Success should me measured by doing what you love, not how much money you make doing it. If it was just about making money, an astonishing amount of people would be failures. I think that this measure of success is inherent in most Americans. This is true because of the troubling economy, and the general understanding of the American dream. The American dream is to find a great job and make money.

I now disagree with the concept of success being monetarily interpreted because it is an arbitrary way to assign someone their true worth. Where did this definition come from, and why is it still stuck in so many of our heads?